US Payroll Tax Withholding Abroad: What Americans Working Overseas Should Know

A software engineer moves to Chiang Mai but keeps his job with a company in Charlotte. Three months later, his payslip still shows the same federal income tax it did back home. He contacts Jorge Rivas, EA, thinking payroll made a mistake. It didn't. Payroll was never told about the move.
US payroll tax withholding abroad depends on more than an address. Who the employer is, where the work is done, and whether an exclusion or exception applies all shape each paycheck. A US employer usually keeps withholding until it gets the right form. A foreign employer usually withholds nothing for the IRS, and self employed Americans have no withholding at all.
Will a US employer keep withholding federal income tax?
Yes, until the employee asks for a change. Withholding for US citizens working overseas works the same as at home, because the employer has no reason to stop until it receives paperwork.
How Form 673 stops income tax withholding
This short statement is signed by the employee and given to the employer. It says the employee expects to qualify for the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion through the bona fide residence test or the physical presence test. The physical presence test requires 330 full days outside the US in a 12 month period. Payroll can then stop withholding income tax on wages up to the exclusion amount. The form is free on IRS.gov. It asks which test applies, the dates abroad, and estimated housing costs for the housing exclusion.
The employer keeps the form, and should ignore it if there is reason to believe the employee won't qualify. The exclusion itself is still claimed on Form 2555, and the form does nothing for Social Security or Medicare.
Pay for work done inside the US never qualifies. Summer jobs back home are a common example for international school teachers.
Just moved and not at 330 days yet
The form only requires an expectation of qualifying, so it can go to payroll in the first months abroad. If the return is due before the test is met, Form 2350 can extend filing to about 30 days after the expected qualifying date. It is only for people still meeting a test, not a general extension. It does not extend the time to pay.
When a new Form W4 works better
In high tax countries like Germany or the United Kingdom, the Foreign Tax Credit often saves more. There, a revised Form W4 that accounts for expected credits usually works better. Withholding reduction is part of Jorge's strategic tax planning service.
What if the host country withholds tax too?
Under IRS regulations, pay is generally exempt from US income tax withholding when foreign law requires the employer to withhold that country's income tax. A voluntary arrangement with the employer doesn't qualify. Local law has to require it.
Qualifying foreign income taxes may be eligible for the Foreign Tax Credit, subject to IRS limits. No credit is generally allowed for foreign tax on income excluded under the FEIE.
Social Security and Medicare on a paycheck overseas
The IRS says wages paid to US citizens working abroad for an American employer are generally subject to Social Security and Medicare. That means Social Security tax for Americans abroad usually keeps coming out, shown as FICA on the payslip. The employee share is 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare, and the exclusion does not reduce either one.
Is the employer an American employer?
Under IRS rules, American employers include US corporations and US citizens or residents who employ people. Partnerships with at least two thirds US partners and trusts with only US trustees also count. A subsidiary incorporated abroad is a foreign employer, even if a US company owns it.
How a totalization agreement prevents double payments
A Social Security agreement assigns coverage to one country. As a general pattern, an employee sent to an agreement country for five years or less stays in the US system. The specific agreement and job arrangement control. The employer requests a certificate of coverage from the SSA, and the employee shows it to the foreign authorities. Only employers and self employed people can use the SSA online request. An employee can apply by mail or fax, but the SSA then confirms the details with the employer. An employee hired while already living overseas generally pays into the foreign system instead. Without an agreement, the employer and employee may owe both countries.
Which countries have an agreement
The SSA lists 31 agreements in force, with Romania added on September 1, 2026. Germany, the United Kingdom, Japan, South Korea, Australia, and Canada are on the list. The UAE, Singapore, Thailand, Malaysia, and the Philippines are not. The list can change, so check the SSA status page before relying on it.
Does Social Security paid abroad still count toward benefits?
Yes. US Social Security paid through payroll abroad goes on the US earnings record as it would at home. For careers split with an agreement country, the SSA can combine credits from both to qualify for a partial US benefit.
Can foreign social security be claimed as a tax credit?
Not when it is paid under an agreement. Federal law bars any credit or deduction for foreign social security taxes paid in line with a totalization agreement. In countries without an agreement, some foreign social taxes can qualify for the Foreign Tax Credit, depending on the specific tax.
Working for a foreign employer
Most foreign employers don't withhold US income tax, and the IRS says Social Security and Medicare generally aren't withheld either. The exception is a foreign affiliate of an American company that has filed Form 2032 to cover its US citizen employees.
Tax can still be owed on salary above the exclusion limit or on US income such as rent.
Self employed abroad: no withholding, tax still due
Freelancers and business owners have nothing withheld. Self employment tax applies once net earnings reach 400 dollars. The 15.3% headline rate combines 12.4% for Social Security, which stops at an annual earnings cap, and 2.9% for Medicare, which has no cap. The exclusion does not reduce it, so zero income tax and a real self employment bill can happen in the same year. Most people pay through quarterly estimated payments.
Social Security agreements help here too. Under most of them, self employed people are covered by the country where they live. A certificate from that country's social security agency is what proves the US exemption.
Ministers and missionaries
The IRS treats ministers as self employed for Social Security on their ministry pay, so nothing is withheld for it. A housing allowance may be free of income tax but can still be included when calculating that tax. Eligibility rules and limits apply. These rules are central to Jorge's work with missionaries and ministry workers.
US payroll tax withholding abroad by situation
Paid by a US employer | Paid by a foreign employer | Self employed | |
Federal income tax withheld | Yes, unless the exemption form or a new Form W4 is submitted | Usually no | No, estimated payments instead |
Social Security and Medicare (FICA) | Usually yes, 7.65% employee share | Usually no, unless Form 2032 applies | 15.3% SE tax |
Reduced by the exclusion | Income tax only | Income tax only | Income tax only |
Relief from two systems | Coverage certificate if sent to an agreement country | Local system usually applies | Agreement usually follows residence |
Can a former state keep withholding?
It can. Each state sets its own rules, and updating the payroll address does not automatically end a former state's claim. California, for example, does not allow the FEIE, so a California resident can owe state tax on pay that is tax free federally. Keeping a home, a driver's license, or voter registration in the old state can keep someone a resident on paper.
What if too little was withheld?
Americans living abroad get an automatic extension to June 15 to file, but the IRS charges interest on unpaid tax from April 15. An estimated payment keeps that interest from building.
How to fix withholding this year
Withholding can be changed at any point in the year:
Check the latest payslip for each tax line: federal, Social Security, Medicare, state, and foreign.
Decide whether the exclusion or the Foreign Tax Credit fits better.
Give payroll the exemption form or a revised Form W4 based on that choice.
If sent to an agreement country, ask HR whether a coverage certificate was requested.
A new form only changes future paychecks. Tax already withheld usually comes back as a refund at filing.
Get your payslip checked before the next pay cycle
Wrong withholding either holds back money you could keep or builds a bill due next spring. A free 15 minute consultation with Jorge shows which one is happening. Have the latest payslip and employment contract ready.
Jorge checks what is withheld, which form fits, and whether a coverage certificate or old state is an issue. He is an IRS Enrolled Agent listed in the IRS Tax Professional Directory, working fully remotely with Americans in more than 15 countries. Book through the contact page, call (803) 467 5815 or (843) 353 0571, or email Jorge.Rivas@RatliffCPAFirm.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Form 673 get sent to the IRS?+
No. It goes to the employer, who keeps it on file.
Does the exemption form need to be renewed?+
Yes. It covers one tax year, so payroll needs a new one each year.
Does the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion reduce self employment tax?+
No. The exclusion only lowers income tax.
What if a foreign company pays through a US payroll provider?+
Not automatically US rules. It depends on who the legal employer is, so check the employment contract.
Do Americans abroad need to make estimated payments?+
Yes, when withholding, credits, and the exclusion won't cover the tax owed.
How can someone tell if they are paying Social Security to two countries?+
Look for both US and foreign social security lines on the payslip. In an agreement country without a certificate of coverage, that may be a mistake.
Does every American abroad have to file every year?+
Not always. Americans abroad follow the same federal filing thresholds as people in the US, based on income and circumstances. Anyone claiming the FEIE must file a return to claim it.
Let's Run Your Numbers
The only way to know which is better for you is to model both. Book a free consultation and I'll show you the difference for your country and income.
Schedule Free Consultation →- Jorge I. Rivas, EA
- (803) 467-5815
- Jorge.Rivas@RatliffCPAFirm.com



